The Ethical Imperative

Judaism requires a compassionate attitude toward all living things due to its strong emphasis on the sanctity of life and the prohibition against causing needless suffering. This moral code, called tzaar baalei chayim, forces us to actively strive for a society in which every animal is treated with respect and decency. The issue of puppy mills requires our immediate and unwavering attention.

The Reality of Puppy Mills

The cruel breeding methods used by puppy mills, which put financial gain ahead of the welfare of the animals, are a disgrace to our society. These establishments often hold breeding dogs in small cages, depriving them of basic needs like proper exercise, socialization, and medical attention. 

The Humane Society of the United States¹ defines a puppy mill as: “An inhumane commercial dog breeding facility where the dog’s health is neglected in an effort to keep overhead costs low and increase profits.” Oftentimes, Breeding dogs are housed in appalling conditions, and afflicted with a variety of illnesses such as skin conditions, respiratory infections, and birth defects.

The psychological effects of confinement are just as disastrous. These dogs inhabit arid habitats devoid of any significant social contact or environmental stimulation. Chronic stress can cause behavioral issues, like aggression, anxiety, and self-destructive behavior. When Breeding is no longer profitable, dogs are abandoned, sold to research facilities, or put to death. Jewish ethical standards are flagrantly broken by this heartless disregard for their lives. ²

The Jewish Perspective on Animal Welfare

Even if an animal belongs to an enemy, the Torah expressly tells us to assist it when it is in need.

You must assist in raising your enemy’s donkey when you see it lying under its burden, even if you would prefer not to do, so says (Exodus 23:5). ³

The Talmud’s extension of this idea in Tractate Bava Metzia (32b) highlights the Jewish duty to spare all animals from suffering.⁴

Additionally, Yehudah HaChasid, a medieval rabbi, reminds us in The Book of the Pious⁵, that it is a serious sin to subject any animal to needless suffering. He states that one must be brought to justice if he caused an animal to suffer without a valid reason, such as beating an animal or placing an excessively heavy load on it. 

These teachings emphasize the Jewish Imperative to strive toward a world where all beings are treated with compassion and respect.

Taking Action

As diligent members of the Jewish faith, we have a moral duty to oppose puppy mills.  Stopping puppy mills calls for diversified strategies:

• Make Adoption Ethics a Top Priority: It is crucial to adopt from respectable shelters and rescue groups. 

• Promote Legislation: Endorsing and promoting legislation that fortifies laws pertaining to animal protection such as required licensing, inspections, animal welfare standards, and forbidding pet shops from selling puppies that come from mills. 

• Raise Awareness: ​​Use educational campaigns, outreach initiatives, and social media engagement to teach the public about the harsh realities of puppy mills. 

• Support Organizations Fighting to End Puppy Mills: Contribute to local shelters, the ASPCA, the Humane Society, and other groups. Groups like these play an important role in rescuing animals from puppy mills, providing them with care, and advocating for stronger welfare regulations. 

• Choose Compassion Daily: Living a compassionate lifestyle means making intentional choices that reflect our commitment to animal welfare. This entails adopting a plant-based diet, selecting cruelty-free products, and supporting businesses that place a high value on morality and sustainability. 

As Jews, we have a responsibility to advocate for the voiceless and work toward a world where all animals are treated with dignity and compassion. We can significantly aid in the fight against puppy mills and build a more compassionate and just society for all living things by supporting ethical adoption practices, pushing for stricter animal protection legislation and leading lives that are consistent with our values.

Footnotes

1. ¹ The Humane Society Of The United States. The Humane Society of the United States. 2019. https://www.humanesociety.org/resources/puppy-mills-faq
   ↩︎
2.  The Humane Society Of The United States. The Humane Society of the United States. 2019. https://www.humanesociety.org/puppy-mill-research
   ↩︎
3. ³ Exodus 23:5
   ↩︎
4. ₄ Talmud, Bava Metzia 32b
   ↩︎
5. ⁵ Yehudah HaChasid, The Book of the Pious
   
   6. Ibid.
   ↩︎

---